- If I were to take the scriptures out of my work, I might be able to reach a wider audience than just the percentage of Christians who feel it important to study communication from a Christian perspective.
- If I were to reach a wider audience, I might be able to reach unbelievers and they may come to know Christ.
- How many people, who are that uncomfortable with scripture, would actually be interested in these kinds of articles and studies which were written specifically for Christians?
- How many of my articles and studies really speak to the unbeliever?
- Wouldn't I approach a nonChristian in a completely different way?
- Isn't there a reason God directs me to write this way?
- So...shouldn't I leave my writing the way I was directed to write it?
On taking the 'God Parts' out
11 comments
-
Hi JoJo…Just loved this article, and thought I would write my msg. here, instead of on Facebook, for a change.
I wanted to tell you, I had a “shock” at the last job I had, a few years ago. One day, at lunch, I was sitting with some work friends, and mentioned that I am a Christian. Very kindly, one of my friends told me that when a person says that, nowadays, it is “assumed” that the person is a self-righteous, ‘goody- two- shoes,’ politically ‘religious right’ individual!! When I explained that is NOT true concerning me…she said, nevertheless, that IS what people “assume!!”
I never dreamed there was this “assumption!” It makes me sad to think that being a Christian has been “spun” into a not very nice example of a human being!! When did this happen? It scares me, actually, when I think about it..
I believe being a Christian is following Christ’s teachings and example…he had no “agenda,” in his teaching. To me, “agenda” has a bad connotation. Maybe the definition really doesn’t.. :) He loves us…period!!
I am curious about your feelings on what I have said, Jo Jo.
This is something that concerns me…alot. I am NOT connecting it in anyway to you, Hon…you are a Christian…period!Love,
Janet -
JoJo,
Thank for this very thought-provoking post. I grew up in India, so I understand exactly where you’re coming from. You may be interested in a book that my father and I wrote, published by Haggai Institute for Advanced Leadership Training, “Who’s Listening?”
For me, prayer the foundation of any communication. There’s a time and place for everything. As I am open to His leading, He will give me the wisdom and discernment to know how to communicate to a particular audience in the most effective way.
Many blessings!
Anita -
Janet,
I’m afraid it is true that there are some in today’s society who believe Christians are intolerant and self-righteous. It is not everyone, but there are those who have a knee jerk reaction to anyone who calls themselves a Christian or to the name of Jesus. Part of what I teach in my studies is to approach folks in a respectful way. The reason I stress this so strongly is because, in my experience, coming from an Atheist family, there are many times when an unbeliever is approached by well-meaning Christians in a less than respectful way. I also see it on the internet where people who call themselves Christians will blast those who disagree with them in a way that is most definitely NOT Christ-like. So part of the blame for this is the Christian community itself. The other part is the way the mainstream media likes to make examples of those who do this. -
I’ll have to look into your book, Anita. I also believe that prayer before speaking is important, but God also tells us to seek wisdom and learn. That’s why I teach communication skills. Just knowing some simple things about how human communication works can help you communicate more effectively.
-
Excellent article, JoJo!
I think it depends on the purpose of the material and the reason one wrote it in the first place. In your case, I am in total agreement! Your products are intended for a Christian audience, and if you were to remove the “God parts,” the heart of your message would disappear. Perhaps a secular audience would benefit from some of your products, but for the most part, each book you write is founded on Christ and the truths of Scripture, and removing those portions would leave your products lacking.
In our case, WriteShop I and II were written in the context of a Christian homeschool co-op, so it was natural to tuck in a few Bible verses and encourage the students to make sure their writing was pleasing to the Lord. However, the few references to God or the sprinkling of verses found in the Teacher’s Manual could be removed without changing the flavor of the product. The principles of writing would still remain: To write clearly, concisely, and graciously.
There are questions to consider before deciding whether to create a secular version of a product. For instance, did God call you to write for a Christian audience? Are the products designed to strengthen the Christian? Evangelize the lost? Is the material expressly intended to teach Christian principles? Is the material (in our case, how to write) equally important and useful to Christians and non-Christians alike? Would the integrity of the material collapse without the “God parts”?
We may or may not ever remove the “God parts” from some of our products, but I do believe there’s a time and place for meeting the needs of both the Christian and secular communities. We’re not motivated by money, but by the desire to put good writing materials into the hands of those who need it. Someday, we may decide that it’s time to do both.